Skip to Content
scroll

When should we cut our losers?

Our Q&As are emailed in our Saturday Morning Report, find the answer to this question below.

The Latest Q&A

Question asked

When should we cut our losers?

I find your report very educational and also very interesting to read. It is not always clear, however, what is your approach to managing stocks that are starting to significantly drift below the purchase price. For example in your portfolios (and also in mine) you have CAJ and AWC which currently have losses larger than 15% . What do you propose to do with these shares in your portfolios in the future? John

Answer

Hi John,

We often preach that investors need to be flexible and open-minded and this is indeed how we approach positions if / when they drift against us, unfortunately an inevitability happens at times. The question to ask is “would I be a buyer here if I had no position, if the answer is no we need to question if we should be holding the position at all. In other words, have a thesis for buying and consistently question that thesis irrespective of whether the stock is up or down. If the thesis is not broken, hold or buy more, if it is broken or has been eroded, reduce or sell completely.

Alumina (AWC) – we took a relatively small 4% position here and in-line with our reflation view we are considering averaging into current weakness. Our thesis has not changed.

Capitol Health (CAJ) – we still like this position and again, our thesis has not changes hence why we remain happy to hold.

chart
image description
Alumina (AWC)
image description

Relevant suggested news and content from the site

Back to top