Skip to Content
scroll

PCI Vs PCX

Our Q&As are emailed in our Saturday Morning Report, find the answer to this question below.

The Latest Q&A

Question asked

PCI Vs PCX

Hi Team, Please may I have your assessment, on the Pengana Global Credit Trust (PCX) that is about to be launched versus PCI which has been in your spotlight. I understand that PCI is possibly more domestically focused than PCX and possibly not a fair comparison.

Answer

Hi Michael,

The already listed Perpetual Credit Income Trust (PCI) $1.145 is managed by Perpetual themselves that is lower risk than PCX (shown via a lower benchmark – RBA Cash Rate + 3.25% p.a.), is lower fee (0.88%) vs PCX and while it holds a portfolio of approximately 50 to 100 assets, making it diversified, but it’s probably less so that PCX.

The Pengana Global Credit Trust (PCX) which is listing soon is a fund of fund structure, whereby Pengana themselves simply create a portfolio of external manages (with the help of asset consultant Mercer).  They add value through manager selection and importantly, getting access to managers others cannot.

They change 1.25% themselves, then the fund managers they invest with charge a fee, plus there is a performance fee attached that is 20% above the hurdle rate of the RBA Official Cash Rate + 6% p.a  – which at the moment is 10.35%, so you can see it’s going to be slightly higher risk than the more vanilla PCI product because they would want to earn performance fees. They also have a fairly innovative mechanism where holders could tender their shares back at NTA if the price on market was trading below NTA. This is designed the try and address the issue of things trading at discounts on the ASX, although it is limited to 5% of issued units so the jury is out on how that will go.

Both are good managers, we quiet like both products, with Pengana being at the higher risk, higher return end while the Perpetual Trust is a little more vanilla in nature.

chart
image description
Perpetual Credit Income Trust (PCI)
image description

Relevant suggested news and content from the site

Back to top