Skip to Content
scroll

Your further thoughts on Helia Group (HLI) and Inghams (ING)

Our Q&As are emailed in our Saturday Morning Report, find the answer to this question below.

The Latest Q&A

Question asked

Your further thoughts on Helia Group (HLI) and Inghams (ING)

Dear Team, I was at first excited when you put HLI into your Income Portfolio. However, when I studied the stock a bit and read your comments I became uneasy. It seems most analysts think it will hit about $3.50 as a 12 month target and yet it is WAY beyond that even now. It has lost 60 % of it's business and will be seeking a new CEO. It seems that a hell of a lot of things have got to go right to be a winner and only a few things need to go wrong to be a loser. Also, today ( 09/07'25) Trump shook up the world markets with his tariff threats and the rate cut did not come through yesterday and yet this stock went up 4% today. Why? I also note it is only 2 1/2 % of the Income Portfolio and it is rated as high risk. And yet it climbs and climbs. I have a feeling of deja vu as in Whitehaven Coal or ORI in another portfolio. I KNOW you have discussed this stock several times in the past 2 weeks. A 4% rise when Trump is stirring the pot seems very odd to me. Your further comments would be very much appreciated. ING seems to have come back a bit, but, does not look like there is any growth left. It's dividend attracts me , but, I want a little growth, too, to keep up with inflation. Do you think it might be a value trap or maybe it just does not have much potential as a company? Thank you for your ALWAYS wise words of wisdom. I am NOT seeking advice as to whether or not to buy these stocks; I am only seeking more data and more reasons for current events. Octogenarian

Answer

Hi Paul & proud Octogenarian,

Helia Group (HLI) – indeed a “high risk” play in our Income Portfolio hence the low 2.5% exposure, but a couple of important points:

  • Firstly, it’s not just HLI that’s ignoring tariff concerns, the S&P 500 closed within 0.5% of its all-time high on Wednesday night, and the ASX200 less than 1% below its high point on Thursday when we answered this question; at this stage tariffs are old news except for specific situations such as copper and pharma.
  • Our view on HLI is based on the release of capital for share buy-backs and special dividends as opposed to the company’s eventual loss of ~60% of its earnings. With around $1.7bn of capital on its balance sheet, of which we estimate, around ~$600mn could be returned to shareholders, buying the stock at $5, with a market cap. of $1.35bn isn’t too scary to us although we recognise it’s not an easy stock to value. To your point about analyst’s price targets being below the share price, as we’ve touched on a few times recently, there is a level of subjectivity around these, and in our experience, analysts can often get things very wrong. At this stage, the market is agreeing with us, with the stock up 12% since we bought it a week ago. At $5, it’s less compelling than it was in the mid $4’s.

Inghams – the 6.1% fully franked yield over the next 12-months is attractive but growth is tricky to foretell with this volatile poultry producer experiencing 20-40% swings on an almost annual basis over the last 5 to 6-years. We wouldn’t call it a value-trap but more of a news driven company who cannot fully control its earnings with external factors such as feed costs, increasing energy & labour costs, plus bird flu scares influencing the stock in ebbs and flows. However, we maintain a tick of approval with our vote being swayed by the recent insider buying.

  • We like ING around $3.50 for yield and some capital gain, with consensus earnings estimates implying mid-single digit earnings growth over the coming 3 years.
chart
image description
Inghams Group Ltd (ING)
Back to top