Hi Craig,
It all comes down to go old fashioned earnings and strategic forward positioning:
New Hope (NHC) $4.52 – NHC delivering a weaker-than-expected 2Q result in February suggesting they will struggle to hit their FY24 targets. Weak coal prices were the primary issue with the average realised sales price of A$180.6/t down from $A211.4/t in the previous quarter. However these prices still dropped down to $130.6mn of cash generated from operating activities, i.e. even at lower prices, NHC is making plenty of cash and is forecast to yield ~10% over the next 12 months hence we hold it in our Active Income Portfolio.
Whitehaven (WHC) $7.69 – WHC has enjoyed a resurgence of late including a significant upgrade by influential broker UBS , with their price target increasing a whopping 38%, from $6.30 to $8.70. The crux of their upgrade was a bullish update towards metallurgical (Met) coal used in steel production, courtesy of good old-fashioned supply and demand dynamics. WHC has changed the profile of its coal-mix with metallurgical coal becoming the primary driver of revenue, accounting for around 70% of sales after last year’s $6.4 billion agreement to buy BHP’s Blackwater and Daunia mines.
Yancoal (YAL) $5.46 – A solid Chinese owed coal business which we don’t follow too closely but its forecast dividend in excess of 10% over the next 12-months cannot be ignored but we prefer NHC as a “yield play”.
We prefer the way WHC is evolving their business and it appears the market agrees at this stage.