Skip to Content
scroll

MM thoughts on CLW

Our Q&As are emailed in our Saturday Morning Report, find the answer to this question below.

The Latest Q&A

Question asked

MM thoughts on CLW

“Message: If my memory is correct, back in October you recommended taking up the CLW offer at $2.80 and that you were proposing to do the same. On 18/11 you were "bullish CLW for yield" although 3 weeks later you were "natural at current prices". Yesterday you offloaded CLW at circa $2.50 taking a haircut on at least the SPP offer. What happened over a three month period? Surely your radar should cover that period of time and the warning should have been out back in October.” – Colin H.

Answer

Morning Colin,

One of the benefits of the new MM site we’re about to launch will the ability to visit a stock page and see all our past musings about that particular stock. We wrote the following about CLW at the time they were raising capital:

Property operator Charter Hall REIT (CLW) was previously earmarked for the chopping block from the MM Income Portfolio to make room for the purchase of Metcash (MTS), but just before we pressed the “sell button” they went into a trading halt to raise $250m through an institutional placement at $4.65, a 3.3% discount to last trade. We’ll now hold fire on that sale until this raise washes through. We’re in no great rush to sell CLW, however we are very low on cash in this portfolio and did not contemplate increasing our position : MM Income Portfolio

This equity raise was to fund the purchase of 3 good properties. 76-78 Pitt Street in Sydney via a sale and leaseback to Telstra (TLS) for $280m, a new Bunnings property to be developed in Caboolture for $28m and they bought a 49.9% interest in a pub in Darwin for ~$10m.

We continue to hold CLW but are not going to increase our position size through the raise

MM sold CLW although it’s a sound business however the macro environment working against long duration real-estate assets.

chart
image description
Charter Hall REIT (CLW)
image description

Relevant suggested news and content from the site

Back to top