Skip to Content
scroll

Critical minerals manipulation?

Our Q&As are emailed in our Saturday Morning Report, find the answer to this question below.

The Latest Q&A

Question asked

Critical minerals manipulation?

So, as far as I can figure, this whole rout in the critical minerals market has less to do with investor behaviour and more to do with global price and supply wars, given that they can determine who dominates the defence, technology and AI spaces. If that's the case, how are these equity valuations ever going to recover and why would you 'buy the dip'? Further to that, for all the chart watchers, did any of them indicate that this rout was imminent?

Answer

Hi David,

As we’ve touched on a few times over recent months critical minerals/rare earths are indeed a political hot potato with China controlling the ball and the US attempting to level the playing field as fast as possible. A tough task at the moment with China producing roughly 70% of the world’s mined rare earth elements, while being responsible for ~90 % of processing.

The US can buffer the imbalance fairly quickly, over ~3–5 years (new processing/magnets), but a true “close the gap” outcome is going to take ~5–10+ years, and it will likely happen with the assistance of allies, not the US on its own.

  • Hence, we continue to believe it will be hard to truly value the rare earth stocks with Xi Jinping the major determining factor.

From a technical perspective the main signal that a rout was possible, as opposed to likely, was generated when gains become parabolic, in similar fashion to silver, with such moves rarely sustainable.

chart
image description
Lynas Rare Earths Ltd (LYC)
image description

Relevant suggested news and content from the site

Back to top