Skip to Content
scroll

Cut the weeds and water the flowers

Our Q&As are emailed in our Saturday Morning Report, find the answer to this question below.

The Latest Q&A

Question asked

Cut the weeds and water the flowers

Dear James and Team, Wow its at times like this that holding simple ETF portfolio looks like a very pleasant option to the gyrations of individual growth stocks. I mirror a mix of your Growth and Emerging companies portfolios and generally have been happy with my returns. However the last month has been really tough and has left me wondering should I keep holding some of my stock positions sitting on big losses. Namely JHX, MIN, PDN and JLG. I don't expect you to comment on all these stocks and I have read your latest views on JHX and MIN. I am however interested in your latest views on PDN and JLG. (Not personal advice just the MM view on your own portfolios). I have no doubt that at some point in the future these shares could have a big jump, but I keep thinking that there may be better, lower risk growth options I could be looking at. Keep up the great work, its at times like this that your words of wisdom are most appreciated. Charles

Answer

Hi Charles, we hear you!

Some of the moves at an individual stock level has been extreme, with the most recent reporting season being the most volatile in recent history then along came tariffs. The last few weeks have been exhausting, it’s a good job we enjoy the challenge, and know that these times of greater volatility create the opportunity for returns in the future, but we’re certainly being tested.

Moving onto the two stocks you highlighted:

Johns Lyng Group (JLG): this non-residential construction services business has been under intense pressure since its downgrade in February, this is one weed unlikely to be growing in our garden too much longer as better-quality companies get caught up in the “crowded trade” unwind.

  • If we had no position in JLG we would not be buying here.

Paladin (PDN): We listened with intent to a uranium conference on Friday, trying not to be too myopic. This conference included a presentation by PDN which is available on its company page. In essence we don’t believe the positive uranium and PDN thematic is wrong, just our timing, and a little bad luck – Boss Energy (BOE) is up +4% in 2025 but it did not have to contend with 1 in 50 year floods, water supply issues and variability in stockpile quality.

  • If we had no position in PDN we would be accumulating the stock, though a safer way the play the thematic would be though an ETF such as URNM.
chart
image description
Johns Lyng Group Ltd (JLG)
image description

Relevant suggested news and content from the site

Back to top